Insomnia treatment: Cognitive behavioral therapy instead of sleeping pills

Insomnia is a common disorder, and effective treatment can be crucial to getting the sleep you need. Explore safe, effective, nondrug insomnia treatments.

By Mayo Clinic Staff

Insomnia is a common sleep disorder that can make it hard to fall asleep, hard to stay asleep, or cause you to wake up too early and not be able to get back to sleep. Cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia, sometimes called CBT-I, is an effective treatment for chronic sleep problems and is usually recommended as the first line of treatment.

Cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia is a structured program that helps you identify and replace thoughts and behaviors that cause or worsen sleep problems with habits that promote sound sleep. Unlike sleeping pills, CBT-I helps you overcome the underlying causes of your sleep problems.

To identify how to best treat your insomnia, your sleep therapist may have you keep a detailed sleep diary for one to two weeks.

How does cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia work?

The cognitive part of CBT-I teaches you to recognize and change beliefs that affect your ability to sleep. This type of therapy can help you control or eliminate negative thoughts and worries that keep you awake.

The behavioral part of CBT-I helps you develop good sleep habits and avoid behaviors that keep you from sleeping well.

Depending on your needs, your sleep therapist may recommend some of these CBT-I techniques:

  • Stimulus control therapy. This method helps remove factors that condition your mind to resist sleep. For example, you might be coached to set a consistent bedtime and wake time and avoid naps, use the bed only for sleep and sex, and leave the bedroom if you can't go to sleep within 20 minutes, only returning when you're sleepy.
  • Sleep restriction. Lying in bed when you're awake can become a habit that leads to poor sleep. This treatment reduces the time you spend in bed, causing partial sleep deprivation, which makes you more tired the next night. Once your sleep has improved, your time in bed is gradually increased.
  • Sleep hygiene. This method of therapy involves changing basic lifestyle habits that influence sleep, such as smoking or drinking too much caffeine late in the day, drinking too much alcohol, or not getting regular exercise. It also includes tips that help you sleep better, such as ways to wind down an hour or two before bedtime.
  • Sleep environment improvement. This offers ways that you can create a comfortable sleep environment, such as keeping your bedroom quiet, dark and cool, not having a TV in the bedroom, and hiding the clock from view.
  • Relaxation training. This method helps you calm your mind and body. Approaches include meditation, imagery, muscle relaxation and others.
  • Remaining passively awake. Also called paradoxical intention, this involves avoiding any effort to fall asleep. Paradoxically, worrying that you can't sleep can actually keep you awake. Letting go of this worry can help you relax and make it easier to fall asleep.
  • Biofeedback. This method allows you to observe biological signs such as heart rate and muscle tension and shows you how to adjust them. Your sleep specialist may have you take a biofeedback device home to record your daily patterns. This information can help identify patterns that affect sleep.

The most effective treatment approach may combine several of these methods.

Cognitive behavioral therapy vs. pills

Sleep medications can be an effective short-term treatment — for example, they can provide immediate relief during a period of high stress or grief. Some newer sleeping medications have been approved for longer use. But they may not be the best long-term insomnia treatment.

Cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia may be a good treatment choice if you have long-term sleep problems, you're worried about becoming dependent on sleep medications, or if medications aren't effective or cause bothersome side effects.

Unlike pills, CBT-I addresses the underlying causes of insomnia rather than just relieving symptoms. But it takes time — and effort — to make it work. In some cases, a combination of sleep medication and CBT-I may be the best approach.

Insomnia and other disorders

Insomnia is linked to a number of physical and mental health disorders. Ongoing lack of sleep increases your risk of health conditions such as high blood pressure, heart disease, diabetes and chronic pain. Some medications, including over-the-counter medications, also can contribute to insomnia.

If you have a condition or medication that's linked to insomnia, talk to your doctor about how best to manage these along with sleep problems. Insomnia is unlikely to get better without treatment.

Finding help

There are a limited number of certified Behavioral Sleep Medicine specialists, and you may not live near a practitioner. You may have to do some searching to find a trained practitioner and a treatment schedule and type that fit your needs. Here are some places to look:

  • The American Academy of Sleep Medicine website allows you to search for a certified sleep center, such as Mayo Clinic Center for Sleep Medicine.
  • The Society of Behavioral Sleep Medicine website offers a directory for finding a behavioral sleep medicine provider.

The type of treatment and frequency of sessions can vary. You may need as few as two sessions or as many as eight or more sessions, depending on your sleep expert, the program and your progress.

When calling to set up an appointment, ask the practitioner about his or her approach and what to expect. Also check ahead of time whether your health insurance will cover the type of treatment you need.

If available in your area, meet with a sleep medicine specialist in person for your sessions. However, phone consultation, CDs, books or websites on CBT techniques and insomnia also may be beneficial.

Who can benefit from cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia?

Cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia can benefit nearly anyone with sleep problems. CBT-I can help people who have primary insomnia as well as people with physical problems, such as chronic pain, or mental health disorders, such as depression and anxiety. What's more, the effects seem to last. And there is no evidence that CBT-I has negative side effects.

CBT-I requires steady practice, and some approaches may cause you to lose sleep at first. But stick with it, and you'll likely see lasting results.

Sept. 28, 2016 See more In-depth

See also

  1. 6 surprising signs you may have obstructive sleep apnea
  2. Ambien: Is dependence a concern?
  3. Anorexia nervosa
  4. Antidepressant withdrawal: Is there such a thing?
  5. Antidepressants and alcohol: What's the concern?
  6. Antidepressants and weight gain: What causes it?
  7. Antidepressants: Can they stop working?
  8. Antidepressants for children and teens
  9. Antidepressants: Side effects
  10. Antidepressants: Selecting one that's right for you
  11. Antidepressants: Which cause the fewest sexual side effects?
  12. Atypical antidepressants
  13. Bedtime routines: Not just for babies
  14. Biofeedback
  15. Caffeine and depression: Is there a link?
  16. Can't sleep? Try daytime exercise
  17. Sleep apnea, central
  18. Chase away the winter blues
  19. CJD - Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease
  20. Clinical depression: What does that mean?
  21. Coffee after dinner? Make it decaf
  22. Cognitive behavioral therapy
  23. CPAP machines: Tips for avoiding 10 common problems
  24. Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease
  25. Depression and anxiety: Can I have both?
  26. Depression, anxiety and exercise
  27. Depression: Diagnosis is key
  28. Depression in women: Understanding the gender gap
  29. Depression (major depressive disorder)
  30. Depression: Provide support, encouragement
  31. Depression: Supporting a family member or friend
  32. Does obstructive sleep apnea increase my risk for Alzheimer's disease?
  33. Drug addiction (substance use disorder)
  34. Sleep and psoriatic arthritis
  35. Fatigue
  36. Fish oil and depression
  37. Foods and sleep
  38. Global Bridges
  39. Headaches and stress
  40. Sleep guidelines
  41. How opioid addiction occurs
  42. How to get used to positive airway pressure (PAP) therapy
  43. How to tell if a loved one is abusing opioids
  44. How to use opioids safely
  45. Huntington's disease
  46. Improve obstructive sleep apnea with physical activity
  47. Insomnia
  48. Insomnia: How do I stay asleep?
  49. Jet lag disorder
  50. Depression and diet
  51. Kratom for opioid withdrawal
  52. Lack of sleep: Can it make you sick?
  53. Late-day exercise
  54. Lexapro side effects: Is breast tenderness common?
  55. Light therapy
  56. Living better with obstructive sleep apnea
  57. Making sense of obstructive sleep apnea treatments
  58. Male depression: Understanding the issues
  59. MAOIs and diet: Is it necessary to restrict tyramine?
  60. Marijuana and depression
  61. Mayo Clinic Minute: What you should know about bats and rabies
  62. Melatonin side effects
  63. Mild depression: Are antidepressants effective?
  64. Monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs)
  65. Napping do's and don'ts
  66. Natural remedies for depression: Are they effective?
  67. Nervous breakdown: What does it mean?
  68. Nicotine dependence
  69. Not tired? Don't go to bed
  70. Sleep apnea, obstructive
  71. Obstructive Sleep Apnea
  72. Obstructive sleep apnea: How quickly will I see results from treatment?
  73. Opioids and other drugs: What to watch for
  74. Pain and depression: Is there a link?
  75. Pinworm infection
  76. Polysomnography (sleep study)
  77. Porphyria
  78. Post-concussion syndrome
  79. Postpartum depression
  80. Postpartum thyroiditis
  81. Premenstrual dysphoric disorder
  82. Premenstrual syndrome (PMS)
  83. Prescription drug abuse
  84. Prescription sleeping pills: What's right for you?
  85. Pulmonary edema
  86. Rabies
  87. Seasonal affective disorder (SAD)
  88. Choosing a light box
  89. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs)
  90. Serotonin and norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs)
  91. Shift work and daytime sleep
  92. Skip booze for better sleep
  93. Antihistamines for insomnia
  94. OTC sleep aids
  95. Sleep and weight gain: What's the connection?
  96. Sleep apnea
  97. Sleep apnea and caffeine: Any connection?
  98. Sleep tips
  99. CPAP masks
  100. Smoking and rheumatoid arthritis: What's the risk?
  101. Stress symptoms
  102. Take headache relief into your own hands
  103. Tapering off opioids: When and how
  104. Teen depression
  105. Tension headache
  106. Relieving tension-type headaches
  107. Treating pain: When is an opioid the right choice?
  108. Treatment-resistant depression
  109. Tricyclic antidepressants and tetracyclic antidepressants
  110. Valerian: A safe and effective herbal sleep aid?
  111. CPAP: How it works
  112. Obstructive sleep apnea: What happens?
  113. Vitamin B-12 and depression
  114. What are opioids and why are they dangerous?
  115. What is reflexology?